This reminds me: years ago I started using a guidance textbook that was based on problem-solving, setting limits, respecting children, etc. Without fail, every semester an African-American student would argue that it was part of her culture to spank young children, and that it was just a white thing (based on white research) that said spanking is harmful. I always answered as best I could, but hey! I'm white! Then, in the second or third edition of the textbook, the author addressed this in the intro! She said she had heard this same stance from quite a few people since publishing her book, and that she had an African-American friend/colleague to whom she took the issue. Her friend responded that she had herself been to Africa, and that she had witness that most African families that she interacted with (and studied?) (and, of course, there are many nationalities and cultures in Africa) treated their children very gently and lovingly when they misbehaved. She concluded that the idea that spanking children is part of African-American culture (and many times it's more than a spanking ; it's a whipping) is part of the legacy of slavery. In other words, the slave master whipped his slaves, and the lesson taught and learned was that those in power use physical force to control those "under" them.
So back to CLASS. I agree that implicit bias is very likely at work in the example I described when I was double-coding. I think the person with whom I was coding probably does buy into the idea that it's OK to be more harsh with African-American children, especially boys.
And this might sound judgmental, and I'll try to be careful how I say this, but! I think that not only might there have been some plain old bias against CLASS in general coming from the participants who stated that it is normed on how "white women talk to children," but (and this is where I want to be careful) I think they were also trying real hard to be "woke" white women. I wanted to ask where they had seen research supporting what they were saying, but the session was over, and people were walking away.
------------------------------
Cathleen McAuliffe
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 06-18-2018 11:21
From: Marielle Sheridan
Subject: Bias in CLASS?
@Cathleen McAuliffe Thanks for sharing an example of this issue from your experience! Your post really draws attention to the fact that double coding can be an effective way of making these conversations happen and checking our own biases. I said in my earlier post that I think the CLASS measure itself is pretty universally applicable, but that does ignore that the CLASS measure can only be used by human observers, who all bring their implicit biases to the table when they walk in the room. I love the idea of recommending that double coding partners be from different backgrounds as a way of developing greater sensitivity to personal bias.
I also think @Angela Searcy is right to be concerned about the suggestion that African American children can "take" higher levels of negativity, and I'm glad she called this out as problematic. We can't really know what code was right in the scenario you were describing without having been there in the room with you, but one thing to consider in similar situations is how the children's reactions affected the *depth* or *intensity* of the negativity. It sounds like you were seeing evidence of sarcasm/disrespect on the part of the teacher, and I don't think I'd want to write it off entirely, regardless of how the children responded. It's not like it didn't happen, right? Whether or not you consider it low or mid range might be affected by the intensity of the negativity, but I wouldn't want to say it "doesn't count."
As far as research to look at, one of the main studies I'm aware of domestically is this one:
Downer, J.T., López, M.L., Grimm, K., Hamagami, A., Pianta, R.C., & Howes, C. (2011). Observations of teacher-child interactions in classrooms serving Latinos and dual language learners: Applicability of the Classroom Assessment Scoring System in diverse settings. Early Childhood Research Quarterly.
However, there has also been a lot of research around validating the CLASS tool done internationally. I'm not sure where the research has been published, but you can see one example of this work described in this blog post: How Ecuador is Using CLASS to Close the Gap
| Teachstone |
remove preview |
|
| How Ecuador is Using CLASS to Close the Gap |
| Did you know that CLASS is now being used in more than 30 countries across the globe? Research studies worldwide have already shown that CLASS has been validated in varying cultural contexts. We are excited to launch an internationally-focused blog on CLASS use around the world called Country Spotlight. |
| View this on Teachstone > |
|
|
.
Thank you all for engaging! @Melanie Horowitz Coyne I echo your sentiment that it's wonderful that people feel comfortable enough in this space to have this conversation!
------------------------------
Marielle Sheridan
Senior Production Editor
Teachstone Training
------------------------------
Original Message:
Sent: 06-15-2018 09:24
From: Cathleen McAuliffe
Subject: Bias in CLASS?
I was double coding several years ago with an African-American colleague in a classroom that was 100% African-American children with African-American teachers. When we reviewed our observations and ratings, there was only one area where there was a discrepancy. I had coded a 3 in Negative Climate because one of the teachers teased and used sarcasm sometimes. My colleague had coded a 1 in Negative Climate, and it was clear when we discussed our different perspectives that this was a cultural issue. Remembering what my trainer(s) have always said -- how did the children respond -- I realized that it really was NOT a negative experience for the children. They "got it." Therefore, I was willing to change my rating for that dimension.
This was my thought when I was having that discussion a couple of days ago -- I believe that the domains and dimensions apply to all children. And that it's up to me to be culturally sensitive. But what if I hadn't been double coding during this observation? Hmmm...
------------------------------
Cathleen McAuliffe
Original Message:
Sent: 06-13-2018 17:49
From: Marielle Sheridan
Subject: Bias in CLASS?
Cathleen, thanks for bringing this topic to the group! There is so much interesting and important conversation to be had about this. I think we should never be surprised when someone points out that there is an element of racial bias coming into play -- they're usually right. White supremacy is sometimes subtle and absolutely pervasive, and as "neutral" as CLASS intends to be and as well-meaning as Teachstone is, we are not immune.
I think in this case there is some distinction to be drawn between the CLASS measure itself (a framework of types of effective interactions and a protocol for observing classrooms) and the examples that are provided in the manual and other supporting materials. Research shows that the CLASS measure is valid across cultural contexts, and the tool was normed in diverse settings. I believe, and I think there's good support for this, that the measure itself is an effective measure of quality regardless of the classroom setting. However, there are ways that a western/white perspective are absolutely written into the manual (I think the examples Maryam gives above are good ones, and I'm sure the long descriptions for each indicator are full of quotes and examples that various users may not find relatable). It is good for us to hear this kind of feedback and think about how we can describe effective interactions in ways that people will find relevant to their own experiences.
I think one of the keys to using the CLASS tool in a culturally sensitive way is to remember that the behavioral markers are just examples. For a high score in Positive Climate, we want to see strong evidence of relationships, positive affect, positive communication, and respect -- but you are not required to see evidence of social conversation or eye contact. The indicators are essential, but the markers are just *some* examples of how those indicators might be demonstrated. Depending on the setting you're in, there may be *other* ways that teachers and children show respect for each other, and it would be important for an observer to be knowledgeable about the cultural norms of the setting they're observing so that they can recognize these behaviors.
I'd love to hear from people who've used CLASS in diverse settings and whether there were adjustments you made to make it feel more applicable!
------------------------------
Marielle Sheridan
Senior Production Editor
Teachstone Training