All Things CLASS

 View Only
Expand all | Collapse all

Bias in CLASS?

  • 1.  Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-13-2018 10:34
    This week I attended the NAEYC Learning Institute in Austin, TX.  I participated in many sessions that focused on race, racism, social justice, etc.  In the last session I attended yesterday, a participant pointed out that CLASS is "normed to how white women talk to children."  My reaction was disbelief, but as we were getting ready to leave, I asked her about it.  She and another participant immediately said that it was absolutely true. They didn't say what their source of this information is.)  I'm feeling pretty discombobulated, and I need some clarification.  Help!

    ------------------------------
    Cathleen McAuliffe
    ------------------------------


  • 2.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-13-2018 11:10
    ​I'm interested to see the responses from those of color!   When I (I'm white)  am doing an observation, I am looking for the respect and relationships that create a positive learning environment.  I don't think that those are in any way indicative of race, but am I wrong?  The children (of all races and backgrounds) in the classes I observe all respond to the positives and have emotional reactions to the negatives which is part of why I doubt this.

    ------------------------------
    Tammy Skaggs
    ------------------------------



  • 3.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-13-2018 12:10
    If this helps...
    Consider that in some cultures making eye contact with teacher is considered rude.  Other cultures don't think calling "honey", "my love",.... are necessarily or indicative of a good practice.   Some cultures consider speaking softly rude, and others consider speaking loudly as being rude.  What is the norm?
    I think we should make an effort to know a little bit about the culture, and look at the children and see if they are happy.

    ------------------------------
    M. S.
    ------------------------------



  • 4.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-13-2018 17:49
    Cathleen, thanks for bringing this topic to the group! There is so much interesting and important conversation to be had about this. I think we should never be surprised when someone points out that there is an element of racial bias coming into play -- they're usually right. White supremacy is sometimes subtle and absolutely pervasive, and as "neutral" as CLASS intends to be and as well-meaning as Teachstone is, we are not immune.

    I think in this case there is some distinction to be drawn between the CLASS measure itself (a framework of types of effective interactions and a protocol for observing classrooms) and the examples that are provided in the manual and other supporting materials. Research shows that the CLASS measure is valid across cultural contexts, and the tool was normed in diverse settings. I believe, and I think there's good support for this, that the measure itself is an effective measure of quality regardless of the classroom setting. However, there are ways that a western/white perspective are absolutely written into the manual (I think the examples Maryam gives above are good ones, and I'm sure the long descriptions for each indicator are full of quotes and examples that various users may not find relatable). It is good for us to hear this kind of feedback and think about how we can describe effective interactions in ways that people will find relevant to their own experiences.

    I think one of the keys to using the CLASS tool in a culturally sensitive way is to remember that the behavioral markers are just examples. For a high score in Positive Climate, we want to see strong evidence of relationships, positive affect, positive communication, and respect -- but you are not required to see evidence of social conversation or eye contact. The indicators are essential, but the markers are just *some* examples of how those indicators might be demonstrated. Depending on the setting you're in, there may be *other* ways that teachers and children show respect for each other, and it would be important for an observer to be knowledgeable about the cultural norms of the setting they're observing so that they can recognize these behaviors.

    I'd love to hear from people who've used CLASS in diverse settings and whether there were adjustments you made to make it feel more applicable!

    ------------------------------
    Marielle Sheridan
    Senior Production Editor
    Teachstone Training
    ------------------------------



  • 5.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-14-2018 09:42
    Hi Everyone!

    This isn't exactly on topic, but I thought people reading this thread might be interested to learn that we do make a deliberate effort at Teachstone to represent the most diverse range of classroom settings we can in our video models. Because the manual does contain a limited range of examples, we try to use our exemplar videos to show a wider range of examples of highly-effective practice. 

    More broadly, we hope that all of our users have the opportunity to see classrooms that look and feel like theirs represented somewhere in our products. Here's a blog post I wrote last year on this topic: A Glimpse Into Video Diversity at Teachstone. We've since added footage from Louisiana and Peru and are always interested in filming in new cultural contexts.




    ------------------------------
    Campbell Buie
    Video Manager
    Teachstone
    Charlottesville, VA
    ------------------------------



  • 6.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 07-09-2018 11:25
    Unfortunately, we can't watch the videos on Teachstone unless you're doing re-certification. I wish we had unlimited access to them, especially when these types of situations come up.

    ------------------------------
    Denise
    ------------------------------



  • 7.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 07-10-2018 14:06
    Edited by Erin Sabina 07-10-2018 14:06
    Good afternoon @Denise Vega Ruvalcaba. Thanks for the comment!

    We do offer 2 options to support programs with Teachstone CLASS videos.
    • For individuals, we offer subscriptions to our Video Library 
      • This is what you receive access to when recertifying
    • For groups, we have our online myTeachstone Platform​
      • Has the videos from the CLASS Video Library, along with an array of additional resources including learning pathways, PDFs, and courses
      • Access to professional development for all age levels
      • In addition to professional development videos and resources, the platform also offers the ability to add and track observation data and create detailed reporting

    Please let me know if you have any questions or would like to discuss further!

    ------------------------------
    Erin Sabina
    Charlottesville VA
    ------------------------------



  • 8.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-15-2018 09:25
    I was double coding several years ago with an African-American colleague in a classroom that was 100% African-American children with African-American teachers.  When we reviewed our observations and ratings, there was only one area where there was a discrepancy.  I had coded a 3 in Negative Climate because one of the teachers teased and used sarcasm sometimes.  My colleague had coded a 1 in Negative Climate, and it was clear when we discussed our different perspectives that this was a cultural issue.  Remembering what my trainer(s) have always said -- how did the children respond -- I realized that it really was NOT a negative experience for the children.  They "got it."  Therefore, I was willing to change my rating for that dimension.

    This was my thought when I was having that discussion a couple of days ago -- I believe that the domains and dimensions apply to all children.  And that it's up to me to be culturally sensitive.  But what if I hadn't been double coding during this observation?  Hmmm...

    ------------------------------
    Cathleen McAuliffe
    ------------------------------



  • 9.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-15-2018 10:15
    ​Greetings,

    So true.  We have to be mindful that even though the CLASS field is level, culture could affect coding.  Perception or reception can often be different and one must be mindful of what is 'culturally acceptable' or not.

    ------------------------------
    Christine Douglas
    Brooklyn
    ------------------------------



  • 10.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-18-2018 11:22

    @Cathleen McAuliffe Thanks for sharing ​an example of this issue from your experience! Your post really draws attention to the fact that double coding can be an effective way of making these conversations happen and checking our own biases. I said in my earlier post that I think the CLASS measure itself is pretty universally applicable, but that does ignore that the CLASS measure can only be used by human observers, who all bring their implicit biases to the table when they walk in the room. I love the idea of recommending that double coding partners be from different backgrounds as a way of developing greater sensitivity to personal bias.

    I also think @Angela Searcy is right to be concerned about the suggestion that African American children can "take" higher levels of negativity, and I'm glad she called this out as problematic. We can't really know what code was right in the scenario you were describing without having been there in the room with you, but one thing to consider in similar situations is how the children's reactions affected the *depth* or *intensity* of the negativity. It sounds like you were seeing evidence of sarcasm/disrespect on the part of the teacher, and I don't think I'd want to write it off entirely, regardless of how the children responded. It's not like it didn't happen, right? Whether or not you consider it low or mid range might be affected by the intensity of the negativity, but I wouldn't want to say it "doesn't count."

    As far as research to look at, one of the main studies I'm aware of domestically is this one:

    Downer, J.T., López, M.L., Grimm, K., Hamagami, A., Pianta, R.C., & Howes, C. (2011). Observations of teacher-child interactions in classrooms serving Latinos and dual language learners: Applicability of the Classroom Assessment Scoring System in diverse settings. Early Childhood Research Quarterly.

    However, there has also been a lot of research around validating the CLASS tool done internationally. I'm not sure where the research has been published, but you can see one example of this work described in this blog post: How Ecuador is Using CLASS to Close the Gap

    Teachstone remove preview
    How Ecuador is Using CLASS to Close the Gap
    Did you know that CLASS is now being used in more than 30 countries across the globe? Research studies worldwide have already shown that CLASS has been validated in varying cultural contexts. We are excited to launch an internationally-focused blog on CLASS use around the world called Country Spotlight.
    View this on Teachstone >

    .

    Thank you all for engaging! @Melanie Horowitz Coyne I echo your sentiment that it's wonderful that people feel comfortable enough in this space to have this conversation!

    ​​

    ------------------------------
    Marielle Sheridan
    Senior Production Editor
    Teachstone Training
    ------------------------------



  • 11.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-18-2018 11:48
    @Marielle Sheridan​ Thank you for sharing this post. I am also glad this is a safe place to discuss this. You bring some great clarity --I think back to the training video of Cars and Letter Stamping. That is a good example. If you remember the children really didn't have a negative reaction if I remember correctly. But I do remember this video was a 3 in terms of negative climate. 

    I think it is important to share perspectives! As a woman of color it is important to I realize I am STILL bias! Implicit bias is unconscious and bias can be embedded in a culture. I do think we have to be very diligent in terms of negative climate because research shows teachers have a negative bias toward Black children.  And that research shows this bias is evident in people of all cultures- including Black teachers. Research shows Black teachers are often more negative toward black children than white teachers with the belief they are preparing them for a harsh world here is the link https://news.yale.edu/2016/09/27/implicit-bias-may-explain-high-preschool-expulsion-rates-black-children

    Your research articles are helpful and I would say trust the tool!
    Thanks for everyone for a great discussion!

    ------------------------------
    Angela Searcy, Ed.D.
    College professor/Coach
    Frankfort, Illinois 60423
    708-845-2343
    ------------------------------



  • 12.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-18-2018 12:03
    This reminds me:  years ago I started using a guidance textbook that was based on problem-solving, setting limits, respecting children, etc. Without fail, every semester an African-American student would argue that it was part of her culture to spank young children, and that it was just a white thing (based on white research) that said spanking is harmful. I always answered as best I could, but hey!   I'm white!  Then, in the second or third edition of the textbook, the author addressed this in the intro!  She said she had heard this same stance from quite a few people since publishing her book, and that she had an African-American friend/colleague to whom she took the issue. Her friend responded that she had herself been to Africa, and that she had witness that most African families that she interacted with (and studied?) (and, of course, there are many nationalities and cultures in Africa) treated their children very gently and lovingly when they misbehaved.  She concluded that the idea that spanking children is part of African-American culture (and many times it's more than a spanking ; it's a whipping) is part of the legacy of slavery. In other words, the slave master whipped his slaves, and the lesson taught and learned was that those in power use physical force to control those "under" them.

    So back to CLASS.  I agree that implicit bias is very likely at work in the example I described when I was double-coding.  I think the person with whom I was coding probably does buy into the idea that it's OK to be more harsh with African-American children, especially boys.  

    And this might sound judgmental, and I'll try to be careful how I say this, but!  I think that not only might there have been some plain old bias against CLASS in general coming from the participants who stated that it is normed on how "white women talk to children," but (and this is where I want to be careful) I think they were also trying real hard to be "woke" white women.  I wanted to ask where they had seen research supporting what they were saying, but the session was over, and people were walking away.

    ------------------------------
    Cathleen McAuliffe
    ------------------------------



  • 13.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-15-2018 11:17
    Hello all 
    As an African American woman and consultant I have had this discussion many times.  I am not sure if I agree that CLASS is normed to how "white women talk" For example, African Americans that are middle class speak more like "white women"  than like other African Americans that are not middle class. Middle class African Americans have more education. So I think we are jumping to some assumptions here. We are not looking at all the aspects of culture like class or education. Could it be that CLASS is normed to how "educated women talk?" I grew up in a upper-middle class community and live in one now we tend to speak to our children in a very CLASSy way! We give lots of vocabulary and ask open-ended questions. But we are all still Black. Having said  m opinion ---this tool is grounded in research. So I am curious about the research on how CLASS is normed to how "white women talk." and if there is research I would look at it with the same critical eye I examine all research -how big was the sample, how many have cited this research and how rigorous was the methodology. 

    I am very concerned in terms of the post in regards to negative climate. I know I am "Monday morning quarterbacking" but I think a 3 is an area of concern. There is a message out their that Black children need more negativity --or respond to it better. There is a lot of  research that shows teachers can often have implicit bias toward Black children--including Black teachers. Black children-boys in particular=-- are often viewed in a negative light and there is research by Walter S. Gillian and the Yale study center that came out in 2016 --Black children were viewed more negatively than white children for same behavior. This is Black AND White teachers that hold this implicit bias and that bias is also reflected in expulsion rates and research on discipline. 
    So key ideas to think about ---
    • just because because someone is apart the culture does not mean they are an expert  on it or they don't have implicit bias. I would also push that person to cite the  data  that supports their thinking and look at that data in a nuanced way. 
    • I think culture is important to explore. I agree that looking at behavior markers as "potentially what you could see" makes the tool culturally inclusive ( like the example of eye contact.) 

    On another note I work with families in poverty with Head Starts and Early Head Starts. I think we are often saying "culture" and thinking about race when some behaviors are due to poverty and stress. When I hear families under the  STRESS of poverty they tend to talk to their children in similar ways and it has nothing to do with race at all. So lets look at culture in broader terms besides race. 
    Great discussion 
    Angela

    ------------------------------
    Angela Searcy, Ed.D.
    College professor/Coach
    Frankfort, Illinois 60423
    708-845-2343
    ------------------------------



  • 14.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-15-2018 12:00
    @Angela Searcy

    There is so much in your reply that I will be sure to read it again, but I wanted to take a moment to say thank you!

    Have you read this study?

    https://eclkc.ohs.acf.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/ta5.pdf


    Linguistic Diversity and Early Literacy:
    Serving Culturally Diverse Families in Early Head Start

    Or this article?

    Julie Washington's Quest to Get Schools to Respect African-American English



    I look forward to your thoughts!



    ​

    ------------------------------
    Susan Hinman Waldman
    Practice Based Coach
    Communities United Inc.
    Watertown, MA
    ------------------------------



  • 15.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-15-2018 12:55
    Sarah 
    Thanks or your reply and posting such these articles! They add so much to our discussion I have a BA in English and education and I take cue from Lisa Delpit and others that study culture. I respect all cultures --I don't say  for example"That is wrong" or  correct children's expression at any age ( I have taught at all age levels infant, preschool, 6th grade-8th grade Language Arts) so I let all people express their thought and then I ask them to translate that idea to fit the various audience they might be speaking with.  So for example, when I taught middle and high school. Students could write a rough draft how they wished! I would read it and then just ask "I understand what you are saying. Would someone from another place understand this?" This didn't put a value on any form of expression ---it was just all about sharing and looking at different audiences. If it was a small child that said " I am fina play with that" I wouldn't correct them put just say " You are fina play with that?  It looks like you intend to play with that toy next- thanks for letting us all know your intention"   I allow children a variety of ways to express themselves using a variety of mediums! That fits right in with CLASS and quality feedback. I also  use repeat what children say, add and expand on what children are already saying and make connections to what they already know which is Concept Development and Language modeling. So I am always CLASSy! 

    So if children speak Ebonics great. If I don't understand I ask for clarity. If children speak Spanish-great. If I don't understand I ask for clarity. I have worked with so many cultures --from Reservations in North Dakota to the inner city of Chicago to suburbs in New Jersey-----each location I respect and value the funds of knowledge each culture and community brings and build on it. 

    I hope that makes sense. 
    Thanks!

    ------------------------------
    Angela Searcy, Ed.D.
    College professor/Coach
    Frankfort, Illinois 60423
    708-845-2343
    ------------------------------



  • 16.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-15-2018 12:00
    I am glad to see that we can talk about bias and the use of the CLASS tool here. I do think the tool is normed to a white collar, educated standard. 
    However, this is the dominant social norm in economically successful power holding groups in western society. To gain access to that part of society, education is key. Strong alignment within the CLASS  dimensions is indicative of programs that prepare children for success in educational settings. Do you agree?

    ------------------------------
    [Melanie] [Coyne]
    [QRIS coaching Lead]
    [Opportunity Council]
    [Bellingham] [WA]
    ------------------------------



  • 17.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-15-2018 13:09
    Hi all 
    Is CLASS Normed referenced? 
    Norm -referenced means comparing to another group of students right? 

    I thought the CLASS was based on literature from a variety of cultures. I know it was based on several large scale studies that were diverse. It states this in the introduction of the manual and I know these studies used diverse samples. 

    Just thinking about how to talk about this in the field 
    Loving it! 




    ------------------------------
    Angela Searcy, Ed.D.
    College professor/Coach
    Frankfort, Illinois 60423
    708-845-2343
    ------------------------------



  • 18.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-15-2018 12:42
    I was looking back at my post and I also wanted to share that when we say "culture' we must keep in mind the variations in one culture. For example, African American parents speak to their children in different ways than families from Africa. It makes me think do all white woman speak the same? There is such variation in culture and each person exhibits characteristics to varying degrees. 

    There also a difference between being aware of culture and bias. 
    Just another thought . Please let me know what you think all! :) 
    Angela

    ------------------------------
    Angela Searcy, Ed.D.
    College professor/Coach
    Frankfort, Illinois 60423
    708-845-2343
    ------------------------------



  • 19.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-18-2018 13:09
    ​My adjustment as a white woman is to really watch the children!  Children let me know via their comfort and engagement what that environment does or does not provide for them.

    ------------------------------
    Barbara Karr-Gotz
    ------------------------------



  • 20.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-18-2018 13:16
    ​Angela,  I really like the point about people being individual...it spoke to me.
    No, all white women do not speak the same way with children and we should never expect that it would be that way.  Not all teachers of color behave as expected either.  We all have strengths we bring to our work with children and we all have things we need to be objective about and change but that is a personal walk that we do for ourselves.  Code the individual you are watching.

    ------------------------------
    Barbara Karr-Gotz
    ------------------------------



  • 21.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-19-2018 09:41
    It appears to me that the best means of addresssing unconscious discrimination is continued improvement on the part of educators. Ensuring that classrooms are dynamic and functional for all students and that lesson planning and assessment methods are fair is one way to eliminate hidden bias. A little reflection on the part of teachers goes a long way toward ensuring that every student gets the education they deserve.

    ------------------------------
    Kimberlyn White
    ------------------------------



  • 22.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-20-2018 11:31
      |   view attached

    I have been eagerly following this thread, and wanted to share an information source that has been very enlightening for us. The Racial Equity Institute offers many resources and workshops devoted "to the work of creating racially equitable organizations and systems". Please see: https://www.racialequityinstitute.com/

    Also, attached you will find a poster, and can also find this FPG Race, Culture, and Ethnicity Committee's Infographic on "What Racism Looks like", the fourth in their series to raise public awareness on racial inequity, and other related infographics. Their work has been eye-opening and 'game changing' for me, and I hope other readers find it informative.

     

    Judy Owen

    Research Assistant

    FPG Child Development Institute

     

     

     



    ------Original Message------

    It appears to me that the best means of addresssing unconscious discrimination is continued improvement on the part of educators. Ensuring that classrooms are dynamic and functional for all students and that lesson planning and assessment methods are fair is one way to eliminate hidden bias. A little reflection on the part of teachers goes a long way toward ensuring that every student gets the education they deserve.

    ------------------------------
    Kimberlyn White
    ------------------------------

    Attachment(s)



  • 23.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-21-2018 09:22
    @Judy Owen

    sharing!​

    ------------------------------
    Susan Hinman Waldman
    Practice Based Coach
    Communities United Inc.
    Watertown, MA
    ------------------------------



  • 24.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-21-2018 10:33

    Oops, I forgot to include the link for the Infographics: http://fpg.unc.edu/resources/what-racism-looks-infographic  A Brief Primer on Racial Equity, Racial (In)equity, Racial Inequities in School Discipline, Examples of Racial Microaggressions, and Racial Microaggressions Perpetuate Inequity are also great sources of info.

    I offer these as a means of educating ourselves, not as a judgement of Teachstone or the CLASS measures. As observers we must not let our biases, whatever they may be, affect how we code using the CLASS 'lens'. Identifying biases (however unintended they may be) is the first step to putting them aside.

     

    Judy Owen

     

     

     



    ------Original Message------

    I have been eagerly following this thread, and wanted to share an information source that has been very enlightening for us. The Racial Equity Institute offers many resources and workshops devoted "to the work of creating racially equitable organizations and systems". Please see: https://www.racialequityinstitute.com/

    Also, attached you will find a poster, and can also find this FPG Race, Culture, and Ethnicity Committee's Infographic on "What Racism Looks like", the fourth in their series to raise public awareness on racial inequity, and other related infographics. Their work has been eye-opening and 'game changing' for me, and I hope other readers find it informative.

     

    Judy Owen

    Research Assistant

    FPG Child Development Institute

     

     

     





  • 25.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-25-2018 15:12
    Hello all 

    Here is the link on teacher bias by Yale. It shows we are all bias --and Black teachers are not immune https://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/oct/04/black-students-teachers-implicit-racial-bias-preschool-study

    ------------------------------
    Angela Searcy, Ed.D.
    College professor/Coach
    Frankfort, Illinois 60423
    708-845-2343
    ------------------------------



  • 26.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-26-2018 12:11
    Thank you for this link.

    One of the things I have my Foundations students do is take the Implicit Bias test. Most students are open to the results, but there is always at least one who says the test results are wrong because "I'm not like that."  It's a tricky situation to handle in class, but I try to focus on the difference between "implicit" and "explicit."  Doesn't usually make a difference, though.

    Cathy

    ------------------------------
    Cathleen McAuliffe
    ------------------------------



  • 27.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-20-2018 13:21

    Wow! There are so many great insights and ideas in this thread. I can't begin to address all of them, but I do want to say that the CLASS was developed and validated in two large scale studies (NICHD Study of Early Care & Youth Development and the National Center for Early Development & Learning). Both of these studies included a large number of children from ethnically and geographically diverse settings. I also want to add that the CLASS is now being used in some capacity in 45 countries. It has been validated in western nations such as Australia, Norway, & Finland and the Latin American countries of Ecuador & Chile. It has also been validated is Israel, Turkey, and China. I believe there are more countries that have validated CLASS but those are the countries that come to mind.


    We recognize that we have things to learn about the use of CLASS in diverse settings. And as an organization, Teachstone is committed to learning more about this issue and are working with partners to deepen our understanding. If you have information to share, we'd love to hear from you. 





    --

    Sarah Hadden, PhD | Senior Advisor, Research & Professional Services
    675 Peter Jefferson Parkway Ste 400
    Charlottesville, VA 22911

    434-466-8203 | Skype: sarah.hadden3 |  teachstone.com 



    Teachstone® | Blog | Facebook | Twitter | LinkedIn | YouTube



    ------Original Message------

    It appears to me that the best means of addresssing unconscious discrimination is continued improvement on the part of educators. Ensuring that classrooms are dynamic and functional for all students and that lesson planning and assessment methods are fair is one way to eliminate hidden bias. A little reflection on the part of teachers goes a long way toward ensuring that every student gets the education they deserve.

    ------------------------------
    Kimberlyn White
    ------------------------------


  • 28.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 06-22-2018 11:51
    Sarah, this has been my understanding re CLASS since day one, so it really threw me when the gals at the conference said what they did so confidently!  They are leaders in their EC communities, and I'm sure they are sharing what is clearly their bias about CLASS with their colleagues, which is a bit unnerving.  I worked in the Head Start TTA network several years ago, and I heard plenty of skepticism not just from classroom teachers, but also from trained, reliable observers.  I heard them say over and over that CLASS is subjective.  No!

    I'm grateful for all the responses here.  I needed to read all of this to get grounding in CLASS back!

    ------------------------------
    Cathleen McAuliffe
    ------------------------------



  • 29.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 07-09-2018 12:04
    I am so glad to see this discussion. Not only is it important for understanding CLASS, but it also affects how we work and interact with others. I struggle with this everyday in both my professional and personal life. What types of behavior are acceptable based on culture and what is never acceptable?

    In the example of the teachers who used sarcasm with children - should that be acceptable based on the culture or should it never be acceptable? While it may be common in the African-American community (as a generalization), and children may appear to take it in stride, what effect does it ultimately have on children, particularly over time? What is it modelling for children? What is it doing for children's self-esteem, and social and emotional development?

    In the example of the use of spanking in the African-American community, does knowing where the practice comes from justify the continued use or should that knowledge be used to educate members of the community (and others) in order to change the practice? What effect does it ultimately have on children? What is this practice modelling for children? What is it doing for children's self-esteem, and social and emotional development?

    To me everything always comes back to the child. We need to be careful when we observe their behaviors because they learn how to respond to others in ways that protect themselves. Behaviors that appear to us as meaning one thing, may be hiding the true meaning (or we could be misinterpreting). We need to constantly and consistently be asking the questions and delving deeper.

    ------------------------------
    Deborah Abelman, M.Ed., Ph.D.
    Director of Early Learning and Coaching
    The Dimock Center
    Roxbury, MA
    ------------------------------



  • 30.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 07-09-2018 17:09
      |   view attached
    Apologies if this has already been shared, but am attaching a 2016 Report from the Tribal Early Childhood Research Center that seems relevant to this important discussion: Cultural and Practice Perspectives on the Classroom Assessment Scoring System: Voices from American Indian and Alaska Native Head Start Programs.



    ------------------------------
    Kimberley Burnett
    Anchorage, Alaska
    ------------------------------

    Attachment(s)

    pdf
    FULL REPORT.pdf   51.03 MB 1 version


  • 31.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 07-10-2018 10:39
    Kimberly, thank you for sharing this report. It provides an additional perspective to our work with CLASS.

    ------------------------------
    Sarah Hadden
    Senior Advisor, Research and Professional Services
    Teachstone
    ------------------------------



  • 32.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 07-11-2018 10:48
    CLASS measures the quality of interactions that prepare children to be successful in school.  Schools are inherently products of the dominant culture.  It's not then surprising that members of that culture (white women) are associated with skillful use of those practices.  I suppose the trick then is working with different cultures to make sure that other quality interactions, interactions that might bring tremendous value to children's lives beyond success in school, aren't being shortchanged in exchange for the practices preferred by the dominant culture, and providing balance so that children can be successful in all of the important settings in their lives.  What a great discussion, and I'm so glad I took the time to read through it - I look forward to more.

    ------------------------------
    Lorine Horvath
    ------------------------------



  • 33.  RE: Bias in CLASS?

    Posted 07-11-2018 17:22
    Thank you for sharing/ discussion / attachments on this topic, I look forward to more.

    ------------------------------
    Mary ThreeMoons-Rogge

    ------------------------------